(719) 505-9999

Why Insurance Companies Minimize Soft Tissue Injury Claims in Colorado Springs and How to Fight Back

Soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs feel like an uphill battle with insurers minimizing your pain and your payout. Learn how to fight back.
Apr 28, 2025
King and Beaty - soft tissue injury claim in colorado springs

Soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs are routinely undervalued by insurance companies, leaving accident victims with inadequate compensation for their pain, suffering, and ongoing medical needs. These injuries—which affect muscles, tendons, and ligaments—can cause debilitating pain and long-term complications, yet insurers often dismiss them as “minor” or “temporary.” At King & Beaty, we’ve helped countless Colorado Springs residents overcome these tactics and secure the compensation they truly deserve.

Understanding Soft Tissue Injuries

When you’re hurt in an accident in Colorado Springs, whether it’s a rear-end collision on Academy Boulevard or a fall at a local business, soft tissue injuries are among the most common consequences. These injuries include:

  • Whiplash and neck strains
  • Sprains and ligament tears
  • Muscle strains and contusions
  • Tendonitis and bursitis
  • Rotator cuff injuries
  • Back injuries and herniated discs

Unlike broken bones that show up clearly on X-rays, soft tissue injuries often don’t appear on standard imaging tests. This invisibility gives insurance companies an opening to question the severity—or even the existence—of your injuries.

Related: The Long-Term Effects of Traumatic Brain Injuries and Why You Shouldn’t Settle Too Quickly

The Real Impact of Soft Tissue Injuries

Make no mistake: soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs represent real and often severe medical conditions. The effects can include:

  • Chronic, debilitating pain
  • Limited range of motion
  • Persistent swelling and inflammation
  • Weakness in the affected area
  • Difficulty sleeping
  • Inability to work or perform daily activities
  • Reduced quality of life

These consequences can be particularly challenging for Colorado Springs residents who lead active lifestyles or work in physically demanding jobs at local employers like Fort Carson or the construction industry.

Why Insurance Companies Downplay Soft Tissue Injury Claims in Colorado Springs

Understanding the insurance industry’s tactics is crucial to fighting back. Here’s why they routinely minimize these claims:

Lack of Objective Evidence

Soft tissue injury claims face immediate scrutiny because these injuries don’t always show up on X-rays, CT scans, or MRIs. Insurance adjusters seize on this lack of “objective evidence” to suggest you’re exaggerating or fabricating your symptoms.

Delayed Symptom Onset

Many soft tissue injuries don’t cause immediate pain. You might walk away from an accident on I-25 feeling relatively okay, only to wake up the next day or even several days later with significant pain and stiffness. Insurers use this delay to argue that your injuries weren’t caused by the accident.

Pre-existing Conditions

If you’ve ever had any previous injuries or medical conditions involving the same area of your body, insurance companies will try to attribute your current pain to these pre-existing conditions rather than the accident. This tactic is particularly common with soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs, where many residents have previous injuries from outdoor activities.

More Information: How Your Pre-Existing Conditions Impact Personal Injury Claims in Colorado

Standardized Settlement Formulas

Many insurance companies use computer programs with standardized formulas to calculate settlement offers for soft tissue injury claims. These formulas often fail to account for individual circumstances, including how injuries affect your specific job, lifestyle, and future needs.

Minimizing Treatment Necessity

Insurers frequently question whether all your medical treatment is necessary. They may claim that your physical therapy was excessive, that alternative treatments like chiropractic care aren’t legitimate, or that you should have recovered within their arbitrary timeframe.

King and Beaty - soft tissue injury claim in colorado springs

How to Strengthen Your Personal Injury Claim

Being proactive after your accident can significantly improve your chances of receiving fair compensation:

Seek Immediate Medical Attention

Even if you don’t feel severely injured right away, see a doctor promptly after any accident. Not only can early intervention for soft tissue injuries can improve outcomes, seeking care immediately creates important medical documentation for your claim.

Follow All Treatment Recommendations

Attend all medical appointments, complete prescribed therapy, and follow your healthcare provider’s recommendations. Doing so demonstrates the seriousness of your condition and your commitment to recovery. Colorado Springs offers excellent rehabilitation facilities like Centura Health Rehabilitation and UCHealth Rehabilitation, which specialize in treating soft tissue injuries.

Document Your Symptoms and Limitations

Keep an injury journal detailing your pain levels, limitations, and how your injuries affect your daily life. Make a note of the activities you can no longer enjoy, such as hiking the Manitou Incline or biking through Red Rock Canyon Open Space. This documentation creates a compelling record of how your injuries have impacted your life.

You Might Like: How to Document Your Injuries For a Stronger Personal Injury Claim in Colorado Springs

Watch What You Say to Insurance Adjusters

Insurance representatives may seem friendly, but their goal is to minimize your claim and their settlement offers. Avoid giving recorded statements, speculating about your injuries, or accepting blame for the accident. Even saying you are sorry can be used against you, as adjusters twist and use your words against you later.

Don’t Accept Early Settlement Offers

Initial settlement offers for soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs are almost always inadequate. They typically don’t account for ongoing medical needs, potential complications, or the full impact on your quality of life. Once you accept a settlement, you can’t go back and ask for more if your condition worsens.

King and Beaty - soft tissue injury claim in colorado springs

Tactics Insurance Companies Commonly Use to Devalue Your Claim

Recognizing these common tactics can help you fight back:

The “Minor Impact” Defense

Insurance companies often argue that a low-speed or minor collision couldn’t possibly cause serious injuries. However, research from the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation shows that significant soft tissue injuries can occur in accidents with minimal vehicle damage.

Surveillance and Social Media Monitoring

For significant soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs, insurance companies may hire investigators to conduct surveillance or monitor your social media accounts. A single photo of you engaged in any physical activity—even if it caused you pain or was taken before your accident—can be used to suggest you’re not really injured.

Delays and Bureaucratic Obstacles

Insurers know that financial pressure mounts as medical bills pile up. They may deliberately delay processing your claim, hoping you’ll become desperate enough to accept a low offer. This tactic is particularly effective against Colorado Springs residents who are unable to work due to their injuries.

Disputing Medical Treatment

Insurance companies often employ their own medical reviewers who, without ever examining you, will claim that your treatment was unnecessary or excessive. They may deny coverage for certain treatments common for your injuries, such as massage therapy, acupuncture, or chiropractic care.

How King & Beaty Fights for Fair Compensation

When you’re up against these tactics, having experienced legal representation makes all the difference. Here’s how we fight for fair compensation for soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs:

Thorough Documentation of All Injuries

We work with your healthcare providers to thoroughly document every aspect of your injuries. This includes obtaining detailed medical reports that explain not just the diagnosis but how your injuries affect your ability to work and enjoy life.

Expert Medical Testimony

For complex soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs, we collaborate with respected medical specialists who can provide expert testimony about the nature and severity of your injuries. Their professional opinions carry significant weight in negotiations and at trial.

Comprehensive Calculation of Damages

We go beyond basic medical expenses to calculate the full scope of your damages, including:

  • Current and future medical treatment
  • Lost wages and diminished earning capacity
  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional distress
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Out-of-pocket expenses

Effective Negotiation Strategies

Our attorneys know how to counter each tactic insurance companies use to minimize soft tissue injury claims in Colorado Springs. We present compelling evidence and arguments that demonstrate the real impact of your injuries, often securing settlement offers far above the insurer’s initial proposal.

Preparation for Trial

Although most personal injury claims settle out of court, we treat every case as if it will go to trial. This thorough preparation often motivates insurance companies to make fair settlement offers rather than risk a jury verdict.

Don’t Let Insurance Companies Minimize Your Suffering

If you’re dealing with pain from a soft tissue injury after an accident in Colorado Springs, don’t accept the insurance company’s attempt to minimize your claim. These injuries can have profound, long-lasting effects on your ability to work, enjoy recreational activities, and live without pain.

At King & Beaty, our accident and injury attorneys understand both the medical complexities of soft tissue injuries and the deceptive tactics insurance companies use to avoid paying fair compensation. Our team has the experience, tenacity, and resources to fight back against these tactics and secure the compensation you deserve.

Contact King & Beaty today for a free consultation and case evaluation.

Our experienced team will handle the legal battle so you can focus on what matters most—your recovery and well-being in our beautiful Pikes Peak region.